Online Marketplace Software: Comparison of the 10 Best Marketplace Systems

With the massive success of online marketplaces such as Amazon and Ebay or Etsy, eCommerce marketplaces have become a popular method for merchants to sell products, systems, or services of all kinds. An online marketplace provides a simple way to reach third-party sellers. Customers are happy because they can choose from a wide range of products on the marketplace. The marketplace operator is happy because they receive a commission or fee from the sellers. However, an operator requires specialized marketplace software for the creation and launch of an online marketplace in order to offer both buyers and sellers the necessary functionalities. Only in this way can they effectively take advantage of the benefits and systems on the platform.

Unfortunately, some of the more popular e-Commerce tools such as Shopify or Squarespace are not suitable for implementing a professional online marketplace. We have compiled a list of software providers for you that are suitable for creating an online shop for both B2B and B2C.

The Essentials at a Glance

1. Essential Characteristics for Top Marketplace Software

An online marketplace requires at least the following features:

• Easy registration for sellers: Third-party sellers must be able to create an account and list their own products on the marketplace with ease. If it is difficult for sellers to list their products, they will go to another marketplace. They also need their own seller profile page to showcase these listings.
• Search functionality: Search functionality is always necessary for online shops, but it is even more important when selling on an online marketplace. Customers must be able to use systems that allow them to sift through the vast product range. This is the only way to launch a successful marketplace.
• Reviews: Because a marketplace will have a wide variety of sellers or customers, you need to be able to conveniently and quickly verify whether the products were delivered as expected and if the quality meets standards.
• Digital vs. physical goods: Some marketplaces may choose to focus exclusively on digital products, while others may restrict themselves to physical, tangible goods such as toasters or books.
• Ability to facilitate commissions: As the owner of a marketplace, you will generate revenue that includes commissions or fees. Every marketplace should allow these systems and account for them as standard payments.
• Pricing: There are massive price differences for e-commerce software, which vary depending on the system and requirements. These price differences affect software providers such as Magento, Shopware, WooCommerce, and depend on whether it is a local online marketplace or a nationwide e-commerce platform.

2. The Providers

Below are listed each of the 5 best software providers that can be used for building your own online marketplace in Germany in 2024 and offer a good solution. These providers offer a tool that can also be used in the development of our marketplace software for you and your marketplace idea:

2.1 Magento

Magento is an open source e-commerce system for complex online shops and marketplaces and is among the most popular providers. It is considered one of the best brands for implementing a professional marketplace for multiple vendors or even smaller individual retailers.

The commerce software can be transformed into a fully functional marketplace thanks to specialized plugins and extensions. With the extension, you can offer separate seller profiles for vendors and allow them to create their own content. Sellers can modify various elements in their profiles, such as company logos, images, media, products, and reviews. 

Use Marketplace Registration:

Sellers can register via a simple form. Once approved, they gain access to a comprehensive seller dashboard.

The “Add Product” form allows sellers to list new products. It resembles a backend form that enables sellers to add both simple and configurable products.

Sellers receive their own detailed profile page, displaying an overview of all their products and sales.

Search Functionality:

Customers can search by entering keywords and filter by category, price, relevance, and name.

Marketplace Reviews:

Customers can leave a review for individual products. The admin can approve these reviews.

Digital and Physical Products:

Sellers can indicate whether their product is physical or digital when listing an item. Additionally, the software can be used in both B2C and B2B environments.

Marketplace Commissions:

Marketplace operators can set a global commission rate as well as an individual (per seller) commission rate. The commission button makes it easy to compare all the costs of transactions during billing and payment processing.

Marketplace Price Calculation:

The marketplace extension costs $349 as a base version. Additional community fees or corporate fees, which incur further monthly costs, apply.

2.2. WordPress with WooCommerce + WC-Vendor Pro

WooCommerce is considered a good e-commerce system and integrated marketplace that is ideal for getting started. It leverages the strong ecosystems of WordPress and, thanks to numerous plugins and extensions, can run on almost any website since hosting is also very straightforward. It is therefore a popular candidate for our marketplace software. The software also offers possibilities for easy optimization for any developer to build an e-commerce platform.

There are several plugins available to add a marketplace module to WooCommerce. It is well supported and offers both free and paid versions.

Use WC-Vendor Registration:

Sellers can register using a simple form and list their products from a frontend interface similar to Marketify.

Adding new product options is essentially the same as the WooCommerce admin interface, but they are presented in a more user-friendly way:

Sellers receive a simple profile page with their logo, social networks, product listings, and reviews.

WC-Vendor Pro User Functionality:

You can make a plethora of extensions to WooCommerce, such as adding search functionality.

WC-Vendor Pro Checking Existing Systems:

WC-Vendor Pro allows customers to review individual products. These product reviews are displayed in an overview on the seller profile page. Updates improve the software and fix bugs.

WC-Vendor Pro Digital or Physical Products:

On WooCommerce, a Pro vendor can offer both digital and physical products.

WC-Vendor Pro Commissions:

WC-Vendor Pro supports various commission structures. Instead of a high percentage, they can choose a lower percentage, percentage plus fee, or a flat fee. Commissions can be paid out immediately.

WC-Vendor Pro Costs:

WC-Vendor Pro costs $149. You will also need your own WooCommerce design theme, which will incur additional costs. If you are mindful of costs, you can use a free design from WooCommerce.

There is a limited free version, but the Pro version with CRM and many additional features is recommended for creating and managing your own digital shop.

2.3. Drupal with the Ubercart Marketplace Module

Drupal is an open source content management system that is suitable for developing medium to complex online marketplaces. Drupal has systems for an online marketplace that can draw on a wide range of options. Additionally, a blog or forum can be integrated with Drupal. On the marketplace, sellers can publish their own content and sell their digital or physical products.

Using Drupal and Ubercart is not suitable for everyone because it requires some website development skills. It does not offer the typical drag-and-drop systems for beginners without design experience. However, the Ubercart module provides powerful tools, which also apply to the profile management centers for both sellers and admins. Sellers are allowed to customize the layout and appearance of their own sales listings. It even works with mass payments via PayPal to distribute payments to sellers.

Use Drupal Registration:

Drupal Search:

Drupal Reviews:

Drupal Digital or Physical Products:

Drupal Commissions:

Drupal Price Calculation:

2.4 Prestashop with the Online Marketplace Module

PrestaShop proves to be, at first contact, not quite as intuitive as Shopify or Squarespace for online shops. However, the company has made drastic changes. Nowadays, you can create an online marketplace that can also be customized.

To create an online marketplace, you need to connect your PrestaShop online shop with the Flinken Vielfachen Online Marketplace Module, which allows numerous sellers to list their own products while the admin manages all the systems. This module provides most of the standard features you would expect. However, compared to other providers such as Magento or Drupal, it offers slightly fewer functionalities and extensions. A standout feature is the payment collection method, which allows sellers to collect their payments.

Websites that find a fixed niche and allow artists and businesspeople in that niche to reach customers are emerging as the new trend model in online trade. Share your stories with others if you have successfully run a multi-vendor business, so that new customers can join.

Which Multi-Vendor Marketplace Platform is Right for You?

While all are rewarding options, multi-vendor marketplaces are not interchangeable.

Those aiming to use multi-vendor marketplaces for digital products should also be able to use WordPress + Marketify + Easy Digital Downloads or WooCommerce with WC-Vendor.

Conclusion

Free Consultation